#942 הגיע הזמן לנפץ את מיתוס אהבת החינם: "הפכו את הרב קוק לפלקט חלול" | הרב אברהם וסרמן & הרב איתי אסמן

בפרק זה של הפודקאסט "על המשמעות" עו"ד תמיר דורטל מארח את הרב אברהם וסרמן - חוקר והיסטוריון ומחבר סדרת ספרים על הגותו ופועלו של הרב קוק, ואת הרב איתי אסמן - יו"ר ארגון ׳תורת לחימה׳, לשיחה על סילופי משנתו של הרב קוק בשיח הציבורי והדתי בישראל.
האם אנחנו באמת מכירים את הרב קוק האמיתי, או שאנחנו ניזונים מציטוטים חלקיים שהוצאו מהקשרם והפכו לפלקטים על קירות מוסדות החינוך? במהלך הפרק, אנו צוללים לעומקם של כתבי הראי"ה ושופכים אור על הפער העצום שבין דמותו המורכבת, הפובליציסטית וההלכתית, לבין הדימוי הרווח של רב "מכיל" המקבל את כולם ללא כל דברי ביקורת. הרב וסרמן והרב אסמן מנתחים בחדות טקסטים מכוננים כגון "מאמר הדור", "אורות התחיה יח" והפסקה המפורסמת על "הצדיקים הטהורים", ומראים כיצד הם עברו רדוקציה שמטשטשת את כוונתו המקורית.
מדוע הרב קוק, שהטיף לאהבת ישראל, יצא למאבקים ציבוריים נוקשים ושלח קובלנות חריפות נגד מחללי השבת? האם באמת התכוון שכל אדם ברחוב יכול לעסוק ב"העלאת ניצוצות", או שהזהיר כי מדובר בסכנה רוחנית השמורה ליחידי סגולה בלבד? וכיצד קרה שכתביו משמשים כיום גורמים מסוימים כדי להצדיק אידיאולוגיות של שמאל ליברלי ומחיקת זהויות, המנוגדות לחלוטין להשקפת עולמו?
המאזינים לפרק זה יזכו לקבל פרספקטיבה היסטורית ותורנית אותנטית על חייו ופועלו של הרב קוק. תלמדו להבחין בין "סנגוריה מקדמת" לבין "סנגוריה משתקת", ותבינו מדוע הדרכתו הרוחנית העליונה בעולם המחשבה לא נועדה להוות תוכנית פעולה מעשית סלחנית כלפי מי שפוגע בקודשי האומה. 
הצטרפו אלינו למסע טקסטואלי מרתק שנועד לנפץ מיתוסים ישנים ולחפש את נקודת האמת. האם תהיו מוכנים להתעמת עם מורכבותו של הרב קוק, זה שהציב את יראת השמיים ושנאת הרשעה כתנאי הכרחי לאהבת ישראל? האזינו כעת לשיחה המלאה.

00:00:00 הפתיחה: האם הצדיקים הטהורים באמת אינם קובלים?
00:01:51 היכרות עם הרב אברהם וסרמן והרב איתי אסמן
00:05:21 הפיכת כתבי הרב קוק לפלקטים שטחיים ורדודים
00:10:44 הסכנה בגזירת הנהגה מעשית מתוך הגות רוחנית מופשטת
00:19:27 התמודדות הרב קוק מול תנועות השמאל החילוני והקיבוצים
00:26:06 הפירוש האמיתי והמלא של מאמר הדור
00:38:26 סכנת ליקוט הניצוצות: מדוע לא כל אחד מתאים לכך?
00:48:24 פטרנליזם רוחני: מי באמת מסוגל לקרב רחוקים?
00:53:36 אורות התחיה י"ח: שלושת הכוחות שמתאבקים באומה הישראלית
01:06:56 הסיפור המפתיע על הרב צבי יהודה והביקור בקיבוצים
01:14:50 האם הרב קוק באמת אמר שמוטב להיכשל באהבת חינם?
01:24:18 חשיבות קומת החול והאיזון הנדרש בין הקודש ללאומיות
01:31:07 ההכרה הטבעית והבריאה של האדם הפשוט וההמוני

#פודקאסט #על_המשמעות

Transcript

SPEAKER_01 0:16

Eigold israel, she may have shredded him, the zahov, a chosen, and the case of the case. Shalom shalom. Tov as a podcast, but we should be able to do that.

SPEAKER_00 1:38

So miti, it's a zak mode placati, no, placate, mimela Shithim, wezek Yhidah hat of the way that we have to be able to make sharam. Negilushabad be engagimal pet, Israel. Amilakovlena. La Congresazioni, Lavada Menahel, Le Keren Kayemet, Cole by Goldena, because the mufia, loak call mamash nitsa by growth, by growth, Lloyd Persen Venum because we have a lot of the same. And the people who are not in the world, and the people who are not going to be able to do it.

unknown 22:03

It's a very good thing.

SPEAKER_00 26:19

Yes, I am going to be able to do that.

SPEAKER_02 38:52

So we're going to Sarvanot. We have to do that.

SPEAKER_00 44:44

But it's a very good thing. We have to get the same thing. And we have to do it. No, as we are, I've got ridvas, me, Local Haduda, Likoy Rushalmi, La Vinus. Lord Kulamanim Karev, Ela, O Michaniro, Shu Batsmo, Yeshanedar Koletova, O Shani Reshi yet semimeno Badora Babodorotabaimer nafikmine Zara Maalia, butshili vrit, yet semi meno shelo. Togumhofy? Zero.

SPEAKER_02 50:39

Siluf Sheni, the Mavimil Khamita Munod Vado, Chetum Rumble Benadam, Shata Marelo Tanekuda Tovasholo Vazu machine at smot colour atomelo.

SPEAKER_00 50:48

Ah, at our ken and paternalist, can you?

SPEAKER_02 51:42

And the ideologia, the shikma breastler was a communist, that's the television. Aval, Lagillo and Loch Bla de Ota Bavariani Ochelka, and a whole blade Avarianio Cholo.

SPEAKER_01 53:03

Love the game. It is been no more.

SPEAKER_02 54:32

Can they come up for the pimp? Accordes, Elem Shlosh at Vyota I Kariot Chahaim Kulam Shelan, Bezotashahim Rukavim, Loraka Kwah, Lorakuma Israelita, Damkol Medina, Kol Amba Ulam. Akodesh can, Akodesh, can I universalit, a Kodesh, Shhezebhaza Korelza Machanea, Ahazumer Mefarete, Shloshas yota Terish Myotbehimait Slenu, so it's universal, we have Israel Achata Orthodoxit, Shazebetz Maharedim, Kfish Kmoshlimli Kruta, and Rimimegheshula Orthodoxim Machadim Kodesh, Kodesh Kodesh Kodish, Gama Yomag.

SPEAKER_00 55:50

Khadish Vedati. Kharedi Shavedati, Haredi, Atamizrah Taharedi, Atamitis Vata Kharedi, Oleba Liarishona Kharedi, Vekamuvan, Isha Ishua Shana Takharidi. Coolama Yhari Shem.

SPEAKER_02 56:21

Ay Munavekal Kodesh Israel, Zak Searishona Siashnya Alumita Khadesha, Aluchemet Bead Kolsa Netyalumit Sweetalaf, Shokolat Bekirba Harebe, Mativyuta Taorah Netiata Umah, Achafitzale Khadesh Khaya alumim, Aharisha Yuzman Rav Alumim Bekirba Mitigrat Yadash al Hagaluta Mara. Vehuleh, Azubesomerze Besam alumim. Lokama Medina Pito Avi Aviva mim. M Rosimla Kim Medina, Le Yudim, Miklat Batuh, Bertz, Mishimari Degel alumyutze Mashukurepo Auma, Mashukarepo Bathalauma, Ashlishit Mashukray and Shiu, Tshukural Bemilahit, Haliberalit.

SPEAKER_00 57:06

Shaitan, Mashimah Pizza Holo Dion.

SPEAKER_02 57:15

She Haita Noset Degel Haaskalabara Lorohok, Vadain Yedata Kifab Hugim Rhavim, he namit Knesset Bahtivalu umit, ilolo umit, ilomit Knessetam, Vedoreshetatoh and Hainoshi Haklish, Hamusar, V od Muvan Shematzabarish, Gameta Yamin, Vegam et Hasmol, Sheza Batsem Kaha. And the Marle Loto, Mekashem, if Shabiachem is the Mechaladvarimpo, Lamrochem M Degele Democratia, Lamrochem Akim Laneshek, M lo M lo Glim Degelumio, M Lord Khim Lokimpo Yeshuvim, Vetzhit Yashwood, Anakutim Democrat, Sava, Bishwilla Democratia, Lot Sava Z Liberali, Liberali, Msag Liberali. As Biddyuk, as I know Shimrim, as him gameta Kharadim, Gameta Low Khadim Lotharki Zafalba, Takhim Akvla Vim, or M Mkva Mna Floagovba Khadim Zakvarasya Zikla Sotalakfiya, V sancciot, Vela Lisgorlemono Mkvara Matsbenim, Avalasiya Shvapo, Zasia Liberali, Anachnu Loh Yehulim Bliha Small, and Uma Auma Shalanu, Lo Yekola, Kachamifoshimit What's the East?

SPEAKER_00 1:00:11

Magalzia? As you say, Mapo Mapo Nekuda, and I atium. Beseter, University of Kid Lyota Sino, a Machnisva Mutsi, Beneuvent.

SPEAKER_01 1:02:57

Okay. Okay, they're good.

SPEAKER_02 1:04:45

So is that she mush tell me the same thing?

SPEAKER_01 1:05:04

I at a m shikum of hack, a telemovaka ravta of the Michelaman Ravta of Loki Bellet Chevoto, who loched any balagida today. The stigma. Okay Mutala gets stigma. Shavani Bavomer, Tudima, Madrigah, Hirishana.

SPEAKER_02 1:05:39

Well did the full Piskahat? And Yemer, Schlishmack, Konozo Midmit, Mitsuraf was a mood ainbet, said Amood Yudret, and a shame share middle game, a lock of calls eh, Av Shara Shalloshko, Regga Makatuf Pushia Israel Mesaprim Tehila Shem, Koha Guru Nabi M Lotif. Masa beholm me comodolam ormai Roman Colbaitala Zeugor al Israel. Israel makirkoh Masse Hem stomat, Echmedinat Israel Shansat Israel. So, you know, the other thing is that we should have a kid. Aravkook Sadikima Toriman as the Sikadat al Mazaya, so merit Mishak Pogea, Bakodesh, Valoumyot Aravkook yetani the gunegdob, Blia Blia daughter saniochal khan anitzariche, I've got to be a khakalaho, ni do machal. A deochel layout of the me a baita vitzel. Ken said um as the matzik, ki betum by Nyanima ishim, the gavak cook, Yacholochimugonville be metwayao Merka said, can hef care hef care can hef care can support. As a as a number, Yacholi Otaval, Aval Avaladam Pashuch Watsadima to Rim Imigne Vulumashus we have, as Pitom Shazakhushauma or Tsara Kodesh as Shampitum Kulam Sal Khanim, Avalani Rotella Ksotal Rav Vasterman outsipur sipum mods.

SPEAKER_00 1:11:12

Bonomarche, Roim Niftsim Behavot, Velo Niftim B Kibutzim. Naha, as Henimir called Varim Shtenu, If Holyot, Botozman any Bawasheshamalil Mod, Vegam Khanakinhit, the Himukh at Sum, the Labovelagi, Siklachov Shah Himushlam, Velhamaim, Shabba Mod Mahib, the Himukh Par excellence.

SPEAKER_01 1:14:23

Ah, Metrich's own.

SPEAKER_00 1:15:01

Shaky Du, Shemikaban Shakive B Zihon Viglias, Sanctu Matai, look, fiat.

SPEAKER_01 1:15:28

Rakhas, rakaz, and he tell him to be a khabhina. Okay. Okay, ten a time.

SPEAKER_00 1:16:37

Kolochom dimirdaumitta kodish commu, by himself, yeah. The as Mashekore Zeus Bikwotze a Sim Karaz M V Malhin Adam, it muda Mishashina, Aval Shavnira Vizzi Bushakher Zemet Pakote Dramati, Abal Abbach, Abal Zenoram Kimafroiz Boni Koshel.

SPEAKER_02 1:17:08

Av Aravioshwa Araviosukraman Zhadikliva Hashaza Hitti Lilmothanim, or Marli Sharavko Klamarata Temishpad, Loko Charavku Kamar, Mutovshani Koshel. So Icarat Selaravkuk Zerate Shama Vada Irata or Memut, Adam Kadosh Leon, Adam Kadosh Lorotelli Keshel Bushumar, Lobesinatrina, Veloba Vatram Volor, Cl Digduk, Katan Shallotelli Keshel, Mod, Hazakaval Beholof and Ulla Mars the Ulla and Ashim Kilometarium Slichala Tin.

SPEAKER_00 1:17:45

She Bugam Sakanamus, Korean Shoe, Mesh, Atora, Omere Bisclass, Shafula Sanidrin, Holali Sh got Muslim Chuba.

SPEAKER_02 1:18:16

Mutafani Kachel, the kill the Lord Mutafnikashel, Ukil U Amara de Colonel of the Kalatinum Rimba Bokeh Modernera, Mutaf Shani Kachel, Zeloya Omer Hhaim Shelo, Ula Maratz Mokola Zmaratzal at Kirvata Shem, Uratora Mitswod Zemashinioto.

SPEAKER_00 1:18:32

And Zeke Nakodine, the first time, Litzanim, Echem Korean Benkelokaino and Murim, Kahli Khasamim. But the other thing is, Israel, Kale Shem Skimbiamina Mecarebet, Yaholio Chanhidavka Segbi Smoladhiga Mitsre Haligufash, Melecheta Kodishata Sibu. Aval Maharsi Mazati Tadhiya Nugabi Midame Rubba, inini muchletabelota, ale dayamin me karebit, Vegamzebi Miday do Bezirut Haguna Besratashemidba. Shavilber, Bakamashovish, Kuttev, the Sudva, Lama, Bikavat, Mashaobasmari Borek Fawe, Zoom, America's Vacol, Mekim, Ashlatz, Vod Veno, ashiva Igeret, Shadow Lopes Sam Nota. Um, Dim said Giguelo, I've just said Almoushuva. Um, Ben Midata Val Midata Ya Loya Muzanitzlo, Una Tayotomida. Remember, Enzigam, Im Midata, you termida alha Boff and Kitsuni, as Mida Midata Yamin Mekarevit, Imalhayo Termidayamina, as Sirenazim Smoldocha, Shabosh, Smoldocha, Mimin McKareb, the Coloraion. Avalyot, Shanachov Dimakreb, the Pashutlo, Avadlo Ved Veloya Vod, Varukat small Avadim smalldocha, Lopah, Mesharevit, Aval Avday Shekulam, Pam Sidrazo, Mishnah Ticho, Sepharda Smelly, and the Mm. As Vedi Basov Perek Mayo S Pedimala of Cook.

SPEAKER_02 1:23:56

Avaluab, Nuata Hol, Mashushbetem, Zayahidushelo, So much, Kumata Holvaz, Kumata Kodish, Zayhidush Modgodolf Blah and Hoshog, Mrav Syuda, Moded Gishadavarz, Yesh Kumat Hol, Zikl Kabed at Hol. A Rav Syuda me odd mode, Zaya Hidush Mod Gadosh Zikla Tmiotubad Bashimar Shonot, Shelakamatina, Velola Vuz, Leon Shia Holve, and Shimitishwood, Notrapo's metutelet, Shayom Bazimla and Sha Kodishole, Ara Cola Ramatkalim, Gamaz Bazu Bo Gamaz Bazu Khabala. So Adam Shallowama Bashel Khavro, Shallow Tishaviro, and Lochosh the Ava, the Low Ava, Adam Shall Kavir, would say that the same thing is a very good thing. Can you ashame if you call me a small radicalize? Sinat arishha mukave dolatzi halabrata sinata reshaim.

SPEAKER_00 1:29:21

Ze is karta.

SPEAKER_02 1:29:22

Lo the piscahere. Rakahaga himit mateket, aliedei kwa datum mit bere, medat andat sili, shen ki him sinata rishale vadava, shemarashimbat sam mitmalimalem rachamimbi, tamo kataim velohtim, pochashulas bireta, gmarame fur semet.

SPEAKER_01 1:29:40

Lot gmaram fusemeth, msha gmuhatam fusamo. No rekordano, the podcast, meule, imhrav, liavzini, moriv rabi.

SPEAKER_02 1:29:48

Andrakoshnya lembishpate khat Birshutha, she rabibataim shamsim Noza. Lodzani Roselagid, Anium Garim Love animera filu, ishumer Uitpalel albirionim shia mutu Uitpalel Ma Rabbi Meir, Khashavlat'ma Nachno terk dolimi Rabbi Meir, and Ahnotark dolimi ech Anishwala Mashika haava minash. Ma'elo Bigl Kalam.

SPEAKER_00 1:30:16

Kalkalavala, Vazwit Palelalem, Shim.

SPEAKER_01 1:30:25

Elishem Khutim miktoimutlo, stam.

SPEAKER_02 1:30:29

Aval Mahu Khashav, Aval Mahu Khashavl at smok shwa marze, sh palem shim, shihem, oh chutim, stamtim kazeba bh.

SPEAKER_01 1:30:40

Lo, lo, stam kolhote, palelem shut, kutimik.

SPEAKER_02 1:30:50

Bekol kriat midrasha gadashik al khazal, bh shetamitsih lavin shaza uh synteza, teza, antiteza, synteza, stomeret, rabimerumer codem call tisnai tare shaim. Achzebruria, ye antiteza metla, se tamo akhataimat sam, aval codem cole is the.

SPEAKER_00 1:31:10

Bidi, naya.

SPEAKER_02 1:31:12

Kanke. As anarh zabik with the bikha call me Drashakhazal, shabichavesh, rabekivatsuhek, sha yosim shole rega codon cotikivko. Cono cole kulambuh him azutsuhek, so it's a vinat Vlada Mashwim Malhimbarabitezucheka the call midrashazalgam Ravyosefetsem eh wamarye wamar Yavom Shiach Vanyashev Big Laleh Hamu Song. Pam Raid's and Talmidmechinahad, Kazakatu B Yevom, Meshik, Vany Shevsega, Tleleg Lalik, Lev and the Rotzelhev Biglalim B Sihalab Khaki, Shelhamur, Atarotzel Shevicham, Tsihlavin Kodam Cole, Tzihlagid, Anilo Zelot, Cola, Kfiravit Cola, Nigaim, Sholhinov Dotomoshiach, Ahresh at a Hyatat Fisah, Ruchanita Zot, Az of Charle Mateketze, Velagit Betem Olhin Wat Gum Dvaring Dolim Viz, Besbergadal Becol Kitwe Cook, Shekhagum Potter Ma Marador, Vumer Beton Kodakul Buch, Cola D Rim Lak Vayom Anechnukasul Besu Batsonuta Thatit, Agal Fida, At Zonota Thatit, Sh Mig Zar Moule, Be Rotal Fida Machaneha, Lumi, La Machane Orthodoxy, Mgdolimbi Tishwut, But Sava Kosman, Savat Tsava, Did Gas Machaneha, Mlock, Mloshot Behad, Mloshot, Mloshot Beyald, Anil Hosh, Mikaban Shaniwe, Aniwe Shabud, Benoit, Lano Sait Shvut It's Mm Mr Kodesh's Makodit's World Madim, Shabakan Etano Seumi V Etanose A Torn Beach Vlachen B Shne Badai She Nudit At Kama Shear Lag Dir Both Bevadai She's Gam Lumus's Herschel How's He's How'sita Ashelay Aims Fisasham, Out Fisash Mashiach, Posh, Avalimatamachanote Tatio.

SPEAKER_00 1:35:50

Okay, Padova, Shel Afdal Betel Aya Bada Betel Aviv's Pharisia Yud Betel Aviv's Have I Ashi Lost Rim Hamma Baita Yud, Yudhi's Zoli Zo Shamsele Shabad Pharisia Zoli's Malafito Haver How's He's How's He's Antihardeli Uh Bag Israel Bavoda Signal Plus Minus Ken's Heart's Shama's How's He's How's He's How Do I Sha Bit M Habersia's What's He's A, Fib Holy Fosh, Shou Habit Sweep, Animas Both Sociologi Far La So Ezeka, The Old Pama, Atore Faiman's What's God, Hamanach Shela, Alarosh, Levin Dav Gmarashimus Vimulo B I Qat Mada's Vim Lodge.

SPEAKER_02 1:37:53

Oh, Zehov's What's Lama's Bidiook, Intelligentsia, Intelligentsia, Khoshev Hulali Parad Me'Ala Amon, So Intelita, Anashim Ha Hamuni Bashuk Vhole Intelligent Hoshevali Paradon, Shah, Briabu Hake, Megashemotanu, Yo Tera Tsilave Mahsovta, Zoi Tautia Sudit, Arab Korea Ta'huti Sudit, Taouche Namaker Tsada Barishba Karota Tvyot, Bergashota Tv Yot, Shaloni Taknu, Aval Gamlonit Tkalke Lod Shumar Spa Kulturit Tarbuti. So Intelligents, Gourmim Zarumi Zorim Gourmet Shpimp, Medina Israel, Yudim Shit Kalk Yudim Shabash Lament, Hatsada Barish, Matsu, Gasim Yo Tervi Matsu, Bemelumadim, The Mussarim Balemshava. So, I'm Lotsar, Lotarich, Hamas, Anashim Hamonihim, Ken Loshank, Mash, University, T Votch Lem and Vini Mash Anashimil, Vem Bazim La Hamon, Zimmer Melaktimit's Mm. Azrav Melaket Nit Sutz, Me Hamonabari, Anashim, Bush Machanauda, We Hulash, Butter, Bru Briot, Michel Anashimbe Machone, University.